
Poster from pubsofyourtown.com
When I was living in Ann Arbor as a student, my housemates and I used to argue about TONS of issues dealing with sports. Having two guys from Cleveland, one from Chicago, and only me to represent the great state of Meeeeeechigan, there was plenty talk about the world of NBA hoops. We’d argue about LeBron vs. Jordan, Pistons vs. Cavs, and the ultimate debate of whether LeBron will stay or leave Cleveland in the Summer of 2010 (one roommate stands to win over $100 dollars if LeBron stays). But the thing we argued over most was the weekly NBA Power Rankings on ESPN.com. These rankings are done by Marc Stein and John Hollinger, with each man using different methods to arrive at their results (Stein goes off instinct, Hollinger uses stat based systems). While they have no bearing on the outcome of any games, the PR’s were the perfect platform to spur the battles we had. “Did you see where Hollinger has the Cavs?!” or “No way KG’s Celtics are worse than Howard’s Magic!!!” were the phrases most likely to be heard echoing off the walls in our house. Maybe the greatest thing about the rankings was that it gave us something to talk about, and in a weird way, brought us closer together. No one could ever truly be right, and new theories or arguments would tangent off the existing discussions. Some of the best talks we had as a group started with the Power Rankings.
When you think about it, people have “Power Rankings” for everything: movies, books, and even colleges. There are stats like these for most media topics, and some of the best conversations sprout up from these lists. But what if you ranked the most arbitrary things in your daily lives? What would the list look like? In the
book The Final Four of Everything, Mark Reiter and Richard Sandomir do exactly that, only they use a bracket system. They rank everything from Board Games and Child Actors, to Sitcom Mom’s and State Birds. And you wanna know something? It was the most entertaining book I purchased all year! The key to a great conversation starter is shared experiences, or things we are all familiar with. And this book was full of them.
That’s exactly what I set out to do this week; looking for the common experiences that my readers and I (most from Michigan) had in common….And what better way than to start with an Ann Arbor Bar and Pub Power Rankings? These bars are places most of us have been to; some of them you like and some of them you might not. So whether you are a fan of Rick’s, go to Ashley’s week after week, or completely disagree/agree with what I wrote, hopefully this stirs some kind of discussion…maybe even with your old housemates.
(Note: Each bar was graded on 5 criteria: Food and Drink, Atmosphere, Utilization of Space, Guy/Girl ratio, and informal votes via Facebook, Twitter, and e-mail. Each criteria weighted equally. To see a number’s breakdown, leave a comment and I’ll post my numbers)
10. Mitch’s: The reason why this bar ranks 10th is simple: I’ve never intentionally gone to Mitch’s. If I was at Mitch’s, it usually meant the lines were too long at all the other South University bars, leading me and my friends to dub it “The Overflow Room.” The beer isn’t cheap, you are going to pay cover some nights, and the ratio of guys to girls is likely more than 2 to 1 on any given night. Location is really the only thing going for this bar (located above Bubble Tea), and if I thought Café Habana was a cheap enough for most students, Mitch’s probably doesn’t make the list. In other words, unless changes are made soon, this bar is your last resort on a night out.

9. BTB Cantina: Burritos and Margaritas are the reason this campus gem sits at No. 9. The drinks are cheap ($3 Long Islands and $4 pitchers on weekends) and there is a lot of room to sit and eat your late night burrito. The only problem is that the drink menu really has no variety and the food isn’t that great. It gets packed right after Last Call (2am), and I’m partial to Pancheros for late night food. However, the atmosphere at Cantina is unique to Ann Arbor. I recommend going at least once to check it out.

8. The Blue Leprechaun What was formerly know as the bar/club called Touchdowns, the Blue Lep doesn’t have a lot going for it. The food is not good (the first and last meal I had when I was there was the fish and chips) and the inside of the bar looks like that one scene from Spaceballs when everything goes to plaid. The pool tables in the basement are a less-than-ideal use of space because most nights they end up getting used as tables for your drink and no body actually plays. Yes, the deals on bottled beer (some domestics are $2 on special) are great and the wait staff is friendly. But because the competition for the best bar on South U is pretty tough, I’m looking elsewhere before I stop in.

7. The Heidelberg: Look, I really, really, REALLY didn’t want to include this bar on the list. And if I didn’t get messages from friends saying this was an Ann Arbor favorite, I would have left it out. The Heidelberg is a nice place to have a beer with a meal, even if that meal is going to cost at least $8 (I’m sorry. I’m really trying to be nice here). If that wasn’t enough, saying this bar is a long walk from campus doesn’t do it justice (Who am I kidding? I can’t do it). It would be like walking to U of M’s North Campus to study, when there are 5 perfectly good libraries on Central Campus. It’s just not worth it! There is no way a rational 21 year-old kid on a budget is walking to the Heidelberg in January. Nevertheless, karaoke is a draw for a lot of college kids and the Berg has one of the best set-ups in Ann Arbor.

6. Ashley’s: When it comes to having a wide range of beer and drinks from all over the world, no one is even in the same ballpark as Ashley. Shout-out to my former housemate Hecky for introducing me to this bar, and once ordering one of their rarest and most expensive Belgian drinks. I won’t tell you how much it was, but I’ll just tell you the price for this one drink was split between three people. Ashley’s gigantic drink menu and rotating beers on tap gives you the widest range of beer choices for any bar I’ve ever been to. Whether it’s a beer from Belgium or Kalamazoo, Ashley’s probably carries it. It’s location right off State St. makes happy hour and evening hangouts with your friends extremely easy. The only drawbacks are a scarce food menu (there really isn’t much offered other than typical bar appetizers) and their cramped seating. For these reason, I had to bump it down in the rankings.

5. Grizzly Peak: The first time I went to the Peak, my buddy Stu told me to purchase their “Mug Club” package, which for $60 dollars gives you lifetime access to 20 oz beers for $3 anytime and your own engraved mug (among other perks). Not purchasing the Mug Club was one of my biggest regrets from the past two years due to the amount of money and time I ended up spending here. It is my favorite spot to go in Ann Arbor. They have the best food for your money in Ann Arbor, and was been voted “Best Place to bring a date” by the local papers. Grizzly Peak sells and brews their own beer, which is the only downside because this is the only beer they carry (aside from Pabst Blue Ribbon). But their beer has won awards across the state of Michigan and is widely acclaimed (I recommend the Steelhead Red), so it’s not like you are missing out. When I do my restaurant post, this ranking will definitely be higher. Until then, I urge all of you to make the walk down Washington St for the Peak.

4. The Little Brown Jug: This bar is a lot like former Michigan RB Mike Hart: Stumpy, lovable, and has a good attitude. The Jug gets bonus points for giving the world “Backroom Pizza,” which sells Pizza by the slice for a dollar (1.50 pepperoni) until 4am. I can’t tell you how many times I swooped in during lunch time, bought two slices, and inhaled them on my walk to class. It’s not a big bar, and you usually have to go around 10 or 10:30 pm to guarantee yourself a booth. I like the Jug for its atmosphere because you can sit down, chat with friends without all the noise of bigger bars, and also watch the game on TV. If it had more space, this bar would have broken into the Top 3.

3. Conor O’Neill’s: I’m ashamed to admit I went to this bar only once as a U of M student, but I have tried to make up for lost time in the year since. Conors’ the bar area as you walk in, with plenty of seating as you move back towards the kitchen. For catching with old friends over a beer, this is the place. One of the most underrated things about Conor’s is its food. Often thought of as just another Irish Pub, Conor’s is one of the few places to get great food (even if it’s a bit on the pricey side). I recommend the pulled pork sandwich or calamari.
The reason this bar is so high on the list is due to the fact both students and alumni can enjoy themselves here. A lot of the bars on South University are more student friendly, and the further you get from graduation, the more people might feel out-of-place at some of these bars. Conor’s eliminates that with a good mix of post-grads and students (and also by being on Main Street near some high end restaurants). Its timeless appeal catapults it to number 3.
(No Photo Available for Rick’s…who here is surprised?)
2. Rick’s: (Note: I visited Rick’s two weeks ago and saw a drunk kid, who was out cold with vomit on his sweater, being carried out sand-bag style by a bouncer. Would have LOVED to use that for the photo, but it might have been in bad taste). This is a bar girls love to go to, and one that guys hate to admit they visit. Rick’s has a reputation for being a place for spoiled girls and guys with popped collars who just wanna grind, even though most normal people have enjoyed going there more than once. Yes, the name is awful. They charge cover, it smells of spilled liquor and sweat, and the mixed drinks are not reasonably priced. Their signature “Shark Bowl” is like an ice tea for those participating in an orgy: they pour the liquid in a salad bowl and give you a box of straws for you and your closest friends to share. But if you want to dance, this is the place to go. People love Rick’s because the majority of college-aged kids like to dance and meet people; two things that Rick’s can set you up for on any given weekend. The votes that came in were mostly from women, but its popularity amongst both sexes is evident by the line you see winding around the block after 11pm for a chance to make it into this bar. It pains me to say it, but the numbers don’t lie.
A buddy of mine (who remains nameless for reputation and jinx purposes) had this to say: “If you want to meet women, this is the place to go. Is it seedy? Yes. Is it over-crowded, sweaty, and have nasty bathrooms? Yes. But I can’t remember the last time I didn’t walk out of Rick’s with a girl or a group of my best friends. I look back at the phone numbers I have in my phone from those nights at Rick’s, and I can only chuckle. I’m sitting on a long streak of instances having left Rick’s with a girl (date and/or random). The place is magic if you are looking for women.”
( The views and opinions expressed by this individual are strictly his own and not necessarily those of “Boyer Meets World”…but we wish him all the best in his goal to keep his streak alive)

The Undisputed Champ
1. Good Time Charley’s: I could have gotten away with switching the rankings for a few bars, but there is no way Charley’s belongs anywhere but the top of the list. It is the undisputed champ of the Ann Arbor bar scene because it does so many things well. If you want to drink with friends, GTC has an extensive mixed drink and beer list with plenty of tables. $4.50 iced teas and pitchers are two of the great values this bar has to offer. The ratio of women to men is about even, and the food is really good for just your local bar. If you want to get a brain work-out while you drink, there is trivia on Wednesday nights (an event so popular, people will get there 4 hours early just to get a table for the event). Throw in GTC’s karaoke nights, and it’s the total package! If you want to dance, Rick’s is across the street and often is where most people from Charley’s will migrate to in the later hours. Every great bar night I hadat Michigan started at Charley’s. It’s the site of my first birthday drink when I turned twenty-one, the bar where my friends and I went after Obama won the 2008 election, and is also the only bar any of my friends have ever been removed from for being sick (again, keeping it anonymous in good taste).
I could fill a book with all the good memories I’ve had at Charley’s and all of these bars at Michigan (and maybe I will, someday). But for now, this blog post will have to do.

Housemates (minus one) for discussing Power Rankings...Check